HIGH SIERRA was remade twice by Warner Brothers. The first remake was a trans-genre version, in which the story was reset in the old west. When the studio remade it again in the mid-1950s, it reverted back to its original format, except that it was now filmed in color.
Here are some wraparounds for HIGH SIERRA by Robert Osborne:
I finally was able to view COLORADO TERRITORY and can offer my thoughts. I DIED A THOUSAND TIMES, I can't find empathy for characters Jack Palance plays. Not because he is a bad actor, because first I saw him as a despicable wicked person, which he plays well. Thereafter I always expect his characters to have no redeeming characteristics.
Deciding between HIGH SIERRA and COLORADO TERRITORY is tough. I root for the bad guy to survive and live happily ever after with the only woman he ever loved. I always wonder why I rooted for him. I doubt I'd root for the bad guy in a true life situation. Is it the tendency to root for the underdog? For this concept to be filmed three times, there must be wide appeal for the idea. I almost need to flip a coin to decide. I think Bogart wins the day, because he is able to give that sorrowful, beaten down expression, makes a bleeding heart like me want to reassure him everything will be all right, even when it won't be. HIGH SIERRA wins my vote.
I finally was able to view COLORADO TERRITORY and can offer my thoughts. I DIED A THOUSAND TIMES, I can't find empathy for characters Jack Palance plays. Not because he is a bad actor, because first I saw him as a despicable wicked person, which he plays well. Thereafter I always expect his characters to have no redeeming characteristics.
Deciding between HIGH SIERRA and COLORADO TERRITORY is tough. I root for the bad guy to survive and live happily ever after with the only woman he ever loved. I always wonder why I rooted for him. I doubt I'd root for the bad guy in a true life situation. Is it the tendency to root for the underdog? For this concept to be filmed three times, there must be wide appeal for the idea. I almost need to flip a coin to decide. I think Bogart wins the day, because he is able to give that sorrowful, beaten down expression, makes a bleeding heart like me want to reassure him everything will be all right, even when it won't be. HIGH SIERRA wins my vote.
I also favor High Sierra. I hope the first Fred MacMurrary film you watched was not Double Indemnity. If it was, then you might not be able to find any redeeming characteristics in all the fine comedies, westerns, dramas and Disney films he was in.
DOUBLE INDEMNITY was the first MacMurray film I saw! And Cagney in ANGELS WITH DIRTY FACES the first of his. Palance is in a category of his own. I can't think of anyone who personified evil as well. Loved him in CITY SLICKERS-"day ain't over yet" or something like that. I wonder what he was really like. I don't remember reading anything about his personal life.