|
Post by kims on Mar 24, 2024 15:46:55 GMT
1950 film with the great Mitchum, Jane Russell look-a-like Faith Domergue, and Claude Rains who appears briefly-but always memorable.
Shown today on Eddie Muller's Noir Alley, I was surprised he liked the ending. I don't often like to tell the story of a film, especially the ending. I don't want to spoil a film for those who have not yet seen it.
WARNING I'M GOING TO TELL THE END.
I think it should have ended with Faith killing Mitchum. I have maybe a warped mind, but I don't think noir should have such a happy ending. I realize most do have a somewhat happy ending, but some trauma to go with it. I thought this film ended with too much sunshine and (significant to the film) roses.
|
|
|
Post by topbilled on Mar 24, 2024 16:23:33 GMT
1950 film with the great Mitchum, Jane Russell look-a-like Faith Domergue, and Claude Rains who appears briefly-but always memorable. Shown today on Eddie Muller's Noir Alley, I was surprised he liked the ending. I don't often like to tell the story of a film, especially the ending. I don't want to spoil a film for those who have not yet seen it. WARNING I'M GOING TO TELL THE END. I think it should have ended with Faith killing Mitchum. I have maybe a warped mind, but I don't think noir should have such a happy ending. I realize most do have a somewhat happy ending, but some trauma to go with it. I thought this film ended with too much sunshine and (significant to the film) roses. Interesting post. I can never decide if I like this film or not. I think there are some wasted opportunities. For instance, they killed Rains' character off too soon...it's almost a glorified cameo for him. Also, why are we supposed to care about Maureen Sullivan's character (aside from the fact she is the director's wife), when there's been very little development of her role in the story and she has almost zero relevance, except to provide that saccharine ending.
If I had been the studio mogul, I would have ordered a rewrite of the script. The basic idea has potential, but it's somewhat half-baked. A lot of it doesn't quite gel and it is hardly what I'd call a classic noir.
|
|