|
Post by kims on Nov 28, 2023 16:37:33 GMT
When women were built like women and not beanpoles to make fashion designer creations with those pointy breasts to star in the films. Men looked like men not Arrow shirt ads.
TCM restored this Helen Gardner production-back when they were interested in preserving film.
The film is good. You have to set aside our studio era expectations of costumes and sets and settle for "put together from what could be found."
The horror of this film is not the film, but the soundtrack created for it. At least twice a female sings while men of the army challenge each other-I wonder what made this a good choice? Often there is percussion background music at a rhythm not matching the body movements of the actors. I was offended enough to mute the sound. If you have the opportunity to see this, one of the first feature films made in U.S., I recommend hit the mute button. I think you'll better appreciate the film without that soundtrack.
|
|
|
Post by topbilled on Nov 28, 2023 17:23:03 GMT
It's interesting you talk about hitting the mute button. I do this with ALL silent films I watch. Mainly for two reasons...I find most of the music compositions that have been added, seem too modern. And, if it is a silent film, then I believe I should watch it in silence and concentrate wholly on the visuals. Yeah, I'm strange that way!
|
|
|
Post by I Love Melvin on Jan 28, 2024 14:31:39 GMT
It's interesting you talk about hitting the mute button. I do this with ALL silent films I watch. Mainly for two reasons...I find most of the music compositions that have been added, seem too modern. And, if it is a silent film, then I believe I should watch it in silence and concentrate wholly on the visuals. Yeah, I'm strange that way! Not strange at all, especially in the case kim was talking about. I think TCM had a hand in offering some of these scoring gigs to promising students and contest winners, which is commendable, but sometimes I've wondered if an actual love of film was part of it because, as kim said, in Cleopatra in particular it seemed like maybe the person watched the film once then went off to write without any particular interest in how it would play out from scene to scene. Not exactly John Williams in a recording studio with an orchestra and individual scenes from the film being screened right in front of them. Granted, that luxury wouldn't have been afforded these composers, but everybody has some kind of monitor in their home these days so there's really no excuse for the gap sometimes between sound and image. Plus the synthesizer in some of them is like nails on a blackboard, so inappropriate for the era of the film.
|
|